Like many, I was also waiting for Apple to release new MacBook Pros to replace my 13-inch first generation unibody MacBook, which I bought in November 2008. After months of wait Apple finally updated the MacBook Pro lineup in April. However, specifications of the new MacBook Pros have made the decision of buying the new laptop very hard.
If Apple had released 13-inch MacBook Pro with Intel Core i5 processor the decision would have been really simple. Go to Apple Store and buy the new MacBook Pro. But Apple is using the same old Core 2 Duo processors found in last generation MacBooks in the new 13-inch models. And here is where the problem starts, which MacBook Pro to buy: 13-inch model with older Core 2 Duo processor or 15-inch model for new Core i5 processor, and is the price right?
Lets first consider 13-inch model – the base model come with 2.4GHz Core 2 Duo, 4GB RAM, 250GB hard drive and NVIDIA GeForce 320M graphics for $1,199.00 and the top-of-the-line 13-inch model gets upgraded to 2.66GHz processor and 320GB hard drive for $1,499.00. Base model at $1,199.00 looks reasonable, but since I want Core i5 like performance I considered the 2.66GHz model. However, when comparing specs of both the models it felt like Apple is robbing us off.
There are only two differences in 13-inch MacBook Pro models, higher priced model gets faster 2.66GHz processor and slightly bigger 320GB hard drive. On Intel’s website if you compare price of 2.4GHz P8600 processor ($209) and 2.66GHz P8800 processor ($241), the price difference is $32. And the price difference between 250GB hard drive ($49 on average) and 320GB drive ($54 on average) is $5. This brings the total hardware price difference between the two models to $37, which means Apple is charging $300 for a $37 upgrade.
After seeing the above result, I decided to look at 15-inch MacBook Pros even though it was not my first choice. There are two Core i5 models and one Core i7 model. Lower end 2.4GHz Core i5 model comes with 4GB RAM, 320GB hard drive and 256MB NVIDIA GeForce GT 330M graphics for $1,799. The second Core i5 model gets faster 2.53GHz processor and bigger 500GB hard drive for $1,999. And the top-of-the-line 2.66GHz Core i7 model gets 512MB GT 330M graphics along with faster Core i7 processor for $2,199.
When I compared the 15-inch MacBook Pro with other premium 15-inch laptops on the market from Sony and HP, three big differences were highlighted – first the screen resolution on all the top-of-the-line laptops was 1080p (1920 x 1080), where as Apple comes with 1440 x 900 resolution screen; second was graphics memory – both HP and Sony offer 1GB graphics card; and third was price, all 2.4GHz Core i5 laptops on the market are priced below $1,500.
Yes, the laptops from Sony and HP are not as elegant or well built as MacBook Pros and they don’t offer 8-9 hours battery life, but is the $300 premium for 15-inch MacBook really justified. In fact, every laptop available on the market with NVIDIA GT 330M graphics card offers more than 512MB graphics memory. Apple’s MacBook Pro is the only computer that has 256MB NVIDIA GT 330M graphics card. Also all the premium (Pro) laptops included 7200-RPM hard drive in base price for which Apple charges additional $150.
Steve Jobs stated, “We chose killer graphics plus 10 hours battery life over a very small CPU speed increase (in 13-inch model). Users will see far more performance boost from the speedy graphics.” But Core i5 processors are not just small CPU speed increase, they offer over 50 percent performance boost when compared to Core 2 Duo processors. If Apple would have added Core i5 processor in place of 2.66GHz Core 2 Duo processor and 512MB NVIDIA GT 330M graphics card, the $300 price increase for top-of-the-line 13-inch MacBook Pro would have been justified.
Similarly, for 15-inch MacBook Pro, even the base model should come with at least 512MB graphics memory, 7200-RPM hard drive and 1680 x 1050 screen should be included in price. Both 13-inch and 15-inch MacBook Pros offer considerable performance improvement over previous generation Apple laptops. But last generation MacBook Pros were running on two-year-old graphics cards and processors based on previous generation 45nm Intel architecture.
I normally change my laptop every 18 months on average, as it’s my belief that computing power of laptops doubles every 18-24 months. However, after analyzing all the above details, I have decided that I will break the cycle and stick with my 18-month old unibody MacBook till Apple decides to update MacBook Pro lineup again sometime later this year or earlier next year.
[Via TechzTalk]
